Author: Mark Ainley | Partner GC Realty & Development & Co-Host Straight Up Chicago Investor Podcast
Leaving a high-paying W2 job to invest in real estate full time is a decision many investors think about for years. Steven Meyer made that move after 15 years in management consulting, and his biggest regret is that he did not do it sooner.
Since buying his first investment property in 2019, Steven has run short-term, mid-term, and long-term rentals, adapted when Chicago's short-term rental licensing rules started being enforced, and built a property management company that handles all three strategies under one roof.
In this episode of the Straight Up Chicago Investor Podcast, Tom Shallcross and Mark Ainley welcome Steven Meyer, founder of Best Property Management and Daniel Graham Holdings. Steven shares how he started with a four-unit building in Lakeview, why he opened it as an Airbnb in March 2020, how he underwrites mid-term rentals when good data is hard to find, and some of the wildest guest stories from his short-term rentals.
He also explains why he chose to start a property management company, how his investment company structures deals for investors, and what makes his upcoming project-based voucher affordable housing deal on Chicago's West Side different from anything else in his portfolio.
Whether you are weighing a career change, considering furnished rentals, or looking at affordable housing for the first time, this episode offers an honest look at the math, the operations, and the mindset behind a diverse Chicago portfolio.
Questions We Answer in This Episode
Q: What was Mark's housing provider tip in this episode?
A: Mark reminds listeners that it is early winter, and if you have enough units, or you are buying a building, you will have some vacancy no matter what. This time of year, give your property plenty of lead time, because a unit usually will not lease in a week or a couple of days. Especially in the city, almost no one is moving unless they are relocating to town, and those renters usually look 30 to 45 days out. If you have a December vacancy, you might not have someone moving in until February 1, but you should still get it listed so it is an option for people moving to Chicago. The hosts also repeat a familiar piece of advice: do not sign a 12-month lease that puts you back in the same situation next winter, and do not sign a two-year lease either. Sign a 14- or 16-month lease that ends in the spring.
Q: How did Steven Meyer get started in real estate?
A: Steven says real estate was a family thing. His parents flipped homes, which meant drywalling on weekends and putting in new flooring. He admits he fought them tooth and nail on it, but over time it stuck. After college, he spent 15 years in management consulting at PwC, and the real estate itch never went away. In 2019, he bought his first investment property, got excited about short-term rentals and Airbnb, and started growing his portfolio. About two years ago, he left the corporate world to do real estate full time. Today he owns a small real estate investment company, Daniel Graham Holdings, and a property management company, Best Property Management.
Q: Why did Steven leave a high-paying W2 job, and what would he do differently?
A: Steven was in the partner process at PwC and close to making partner, but the work did not feel rewarding to him personally. Around the same time, some people he loves became very sick, and in his late 30s, working 50 to 60 hours a week, he asked whether he was taking the easy path or betting on himself. He was single, had a nice nest egg, and already owned real estate that was cash flowing. He spent two to three months of focused effort on the decision, talking with family, bosses, and mentors, and working out his income, his runway, and when he would need to decide. Looking back, he would have left sooner. He says a W2 income is very secure, but you are giving up something for that security, and when you are leaving, you think a lot about what could go wrong, but not about what could go right. He also would have started investing sooner.
Q: What was Steven's first deal, and why short-term rentals?
A: His first property was an occupied four-unit building in Lakeview, near Wrigley Field. He describes it as a super ugly but well-maintained building, exactly what he looks for now, because it looks ugly on Zillow but the expensive items are taken care of. Rents were severely below market, so when the leases ended, he let the tenants know they would not be renewed because the building was being renovated. Steven ran the math: if a lease was $2,000 a month and Airbnb nights in the area were around $250, eight or nine nights a month would get him to break even, and anything above that was the gravy. His rule was that the investment had to work as a long-term rental, as is, with short-term rental as the upside. He also found that short-term guests staying three to five nights care more about location and a nice environment than about dishwashers or granite countertops, which let him buy more awkward setups that other buyers passed on.
Q: What were the biggest lessons from his first short-term rental?
A: Steven opened the Airbnb in March 2020. After renovating and furnishing the building unit by unit, he had to switch quickly to a long-term rental strategy and ride out a couple of months. He says operations make or break a short-term rental, because you are in the hospitality business right away, from making the rooms comfortable to handling early check-ins and early bag drop-offs. Because he was still traveling for PwC, he quickly brought on a short-term rental property manager. Startup also took months longer than planned. A single dresser, for example, can take three or four hours to build.
Q: How did Chicago's short-term rental rules affect his strategy?
A: Chicago had short-term rental laws for a while, but enforcement came later, and some of his properties no longer qualified. As Steven explains it, in the city of Chicago, a unit in a building of six units or less essentially has to be your primary residence if you want to rent it short term. In larger buildings, up to 25% of the units could be eligible, with some other criteria. Since you only have one primary residence, that disqualifies a lot of people. He now helps owners who lost their short-term rental license move to mid-term furnished rentals or back to traditional long-term leases. Because every deal he bought had to work as a long-term rental, he was able to adapt.
Q: What does Steven's portfolio look like today?
A: Most of his personal portfolio is on Chicago's North Side, in Lakeview and Lincoln Park. It includes short-term rentals, two mid-term (monthly furnished) rentals, and another 10 long-term rentals. He is also working on an affordable housing acquisition that he says will add another 23 units and roughly double the portfolio.
Q: How does Chicago treat mid-term rentals, and how does Steven underwrite them?
A: Steven says the city defines a short-term rental as any rental of fewer than 32 consecutive nights. Above that, it is treated as a long-term rental, so a monthly furnished rental in Chicago still needs to follow the RLTO and use traditional leases. For mid-term rentals, he says smaller units are better, because guests are usually one or two people in town for a month or more for work or family. In Lakeview, he gets many parents who come to spend a month or two with their children after a new baby arrives. Being near hospitals, transportation, and universities, such as DePaul and UIC, helps, and parking matters more than it does for short-term rentals. Data is the hardest part. Mid-term rentals are not reported on the MLS, AirDNA's short-term data does not really apply, and figures from sites like Furnished Finder usually come from platforms that want owners on board. He hedges the numbers down quite a bit. If a source says a neighborhood can do 80% occupancy, he asks whether the deal still works at 50% to 60%.
Q: What are some of Steven's wildest short-term rental stories?
A: His cleaners take time-stamped photos of every space after guests leave, which helped when a guest left with a broken bed and did not report it. At a property his company manages in Florida, guests checked in and, in the middle of the night, said the place was disgusting, then said they could not send more photos because their kids were sleeping in the beds. During the World Cup, guests from the UK called him around 3:00 in the morning because the keypad had died, and he had to go over and open the door. Steven says these situations used to cost him a lot of sleep, until he accepted that no matter how hard you try, it is not going to work for everybody.
Q: Why did Steven start a property management company?
A: To own a property management business, you need to be a licensed broker, so he got his broker's license, even though buying and selling is not what he is passionate about. Part of the reason was functional, since his investment company may want to manage its own properties. The bigger reason was that many investors treat property management as a dirty term or a commodity, and he wanted to bring the professional, organized approach he learned at PwC to a smaller scale. Many people in his network were not happy with their property managers, and he liked that property management builds long-term relationships with owners and investors.
Q: What does it take to manage short-term, mid-term, and long-term rentals together?
A: Steven calls it software intensive. His team uses one suite for short-term rentals and another for long-term and mid-term rentals, and he says AI and newer technology make it easier to bring them together. For owners, everything lives in one place, DoorLoop, an off-the-shelf property management tool he chose mainly for its owner and tenant mobile experience. On the short-term side, his team handles pricing, guest communication, and bookings. His company has about 20 doors under management, and he is being choosy, looking for owners and investors who have a portfolio and want to grow it, rather than clients who only shop on price.
Q: How does Steven's real estate investment company work?
A: Daniel Graham Holdings uses its own capital and investor capital to buy properties. Steven first learned the model from friends in institutional private equity who let him invest alongside them. Now his company sources properties, handles negotiations, and structures each deal as an offering, including what it expects to earn and the underlying terms. Investors bring capital, and his team manages and executes the project. He says working with a sponsor can be a great way into bigger deals, especially if you have a day job.
Q: What is Steven's upcoming affordable housing project?
A: Steven found the property on LoopNet a couple of years ago and kept in touch with the owner, an older gentleman looking to retire. It is a $2 million property on Chicago's West Side that uses a project-based voucher, which means the federal government leases the entire building. The government offers long-term contracts for the building, which gives more certainty on income, and it offers debt terms that he says he could not get in public markets. The tradeoff is a lot of paperwork, consultants, and lawyers. He believes the downside is protected because the rent was set in the late '90s under a different style of affordable housing, so the building is undervalued compared with market rents. Most of the risk is in recapturing that difference, including shifts in rents and cap rates, since a quarter-point move can change the deal. Because he is very nervous about using other investors' capital, he underwrites conservatively on income and aggressively on expenses. He has also backed out of deals, and his lesson from consulting is to deliver bad news early.
Q: What is Steven's five-year outlook, and what would he tell investors who are nervous about Chicago?
A: He wants to do more affordable housing deals, including near this property, because he does not see much investor competition there, and he wants to keep growing the property management company. For investors worried about Chicago, he says you have to be able to sleep at night, and he will not try to convince anyone. He believes Chicago is a tremendous market, but property taxes keep going up, so ask whether the deal still works if taxes rise 30%. His other advice is to come see the property and the comps in person and do your research.
Q: What did Steven share in the rapid-fire round?
A: His competitive advantage is being willing to figure things out, do the hard work, and use technology and processes, even if they are not perfect at the start. His advice for someone who has not bought a first property is to go for it, start soon, and start small. For fun, he races his Corvette, rides his bike on the lakefront, and spends time with his wife and loved ones. He recommends Jim Collins' Good to Great, Jim Collins' newest book, which he believes is called What to Make of a Life, and 4,000 Weeks, which he was reading while deciding to leave his W2 job. As a local resource, he says to lean into your network and go to real estate meetups. To reach him, use the contact page on his website, steve-meyer.com.
Show Notes and Timestamps
02:47 Housing provider tip: give winter vacancies extra lead time, and use 14- or 16-month leases to end in the spring.
04:41 Steven introduces Daniel Graham Holdings and Best Property Management, and why he left a 15-year consulting career.
11:25 Starting with a four-unit building in Lakeview, and the short-term rental math behind it.
14:53 Lessons from opening an Airbnb in March 2020, and how Chicago's licensing rules changed his strategy.
18:43 Steven's portfolio today, plus how to underwrite mid-term furnished rentals.
25:22 Wild short-term rental stories, from a broken bed to a 3:00 AM keypad failure.
29:29 The pros and cons of starting a property management company, and why Steven uses DoorLoop.
39:11 Steven's upcoming project-based voucher affordable housing deal on Chicago's West Side.
46:57 Steven's five-year outlook, and what he tells investors who are nervous about Chicago.
50:06 Rapid-fire round: competitive advantage, advice for new investors, book recommendations, and how to reach Steven.
Key Takeaways for Chicago Landlords and Investors
Winter vacancies take longer to fill. List units early, since renters relocating to Chicago usually search 30 to 45 days out, and use lease terms that end in the spring.
Leaving a W2 job is easier to evaluate when you know your real expenses, your runway, and your decision dates. Steven's biggest regret is that he did not leave, or start investing, sooner.
Underwrite every short-term or mid-term deal so it still works as a long-term rental. That fallback is what let Steven adapt when COVID hit and when licensing rules were enforced.
In Chicago, short-term rentals in buildings of six units or less essentially need to be the owner's primary residence, so check eligibility before you buy for that strategy.
Mid-term furnished rentals in Chicago still fall under the RLTO and need traditional leases. Smaller units near hospitals, transportation, and universities, with parking, tend to fit the strategy best.
Mid-term rental data is limited. Hedge platform and AirDNA numbers down, and make sure the deal survives at 50% to 60% occupancy.
Short-term rentals are a hospitality business. Time-stamped cleaner photos, solid systems, and a thick skin help when guests dispute damage or conditions.
Property management is not just a commodity. Professional systems and long-term relationships with owners can set a management company apart.
Project-based voucher deals involve heavy paperwork, but they can offer long-term government contracts and debt terms that are hard to find in today's market.
When you invest with other people's money, underwrite conservatively, deliver bad news early, and be willing to walk away from a deal.
If Chicago makes you nervous, build rising property taxes and insurance into your numbers, then come see the property and the neighborhood for yourself.
Your network is one of your most underused resources. Talk to people you know, ask for introductions, and go to local real estate meetups.
Guest info
Mark Ainley
Founder & Partner – GC Realty & Development
Podcast Co-Host – Straight Up Chicago Investor
Guest Name: Steven Meyer
Guest Company: Best Property Management & Daniel Graham Holdings
Guest Link: https://steve-meyer.com/
Because finding good tenants and property management shouldn’t feel like online dating.
Dear Investor,
If you are an investor in either the city or suburbs of Chicago, I would love to speak with you about how we can help you on your real estate journey. At GC Realty & Development LLC, we help hundreds of Chicagoland real estate owners and brokers each year manage their assets with both full service property management and tenant placement services.
We understand that every investor’s goals are unique, and we love learning about each client’s individual needs. If there is an opportunity to help you buy back your time by managing your rental property or finding quality tenants, please check us out.
Best Investing,

Founder, Partner, Podcast Co-Host, and Investor
Vendor Portal

